An unanswered question is still a question.
It only becomes a verdict if I make it one.
It started outside, as a regular conversation about the day that evolved into something with more weight. Over the next two hours, in stages, it became a conversation with some important thoughts and questions in it.
We stopped for a cup of tea, picked it up again on a couch, stopped again for some food, and then for something ordinary that needed doing. The last part of it happened while walking.
It was long, honest, and in some ways genuinely good. It also left things unanswered. Questions that went by without acknowledgement. Points from both of us that didn’t get the neater resolution we might have hoped for. Things I’d really wanted clarity on and didn’t get.
I have an oscillating relationship with ambiguity and unresolved things that are important to me. I don’t always know or remember how to stay with a question that got asked and never answered.
By default, my instinct is to notice the gap, track progress, file it, and bring it back up again in another moment. Sometimes that’s useful, and the passage of time and some reflection helps. But sometimes it’s a way of me refusing to tolerate incompleteness and the discomfort I can feel in it.
I try to remind myself that conversations aren’t documents or debates. They don’t cover everything. They have their own momentum, and things fall out because other things come up, or we get stuck on something else.
The trouble is that when something is at stake and we’re paying close attention, incompleteness starts to feel like avoidance or evasion. Every unanswered question becomes evidence of something, and every dropped thread starts to feel like a door closing.
I know this about myself. My pattern recognition is strong, my past experiences bumpy and hard, and sometimes my vigilance runs hot. It’s difficult to know whether I’ve spotted a pattern or am seeing previous experiences in current ones because some elements are similar.
What I’ve been trying is to hold an unresolved thing without turning it into a verdict, and let it stay that way for a while.
Because the alternative is forcing everything to a resolution before the conversation closes. But that makes for a thorough and exhausting exchange, more like a position paper developed out loud.
I’ve noticed that conversations held with this kind of grip, where everything has to close before we stop, tend to produce compliance rather than honesty. People say what’s needed to end the conversation, not necessarily what’s true.
There’s a skill here that I want to become better at: ending a conversation knowing it isn’t finished, and being all right with that.
Steady enough with the knowledge that it covered what it covered today, and the rest will come in time. That requires trusting there will be more time, which is its own kind of hope and faith.
I’ve also noticed that when I do loosen a little, where an incomplete thing is allowed to stay that way for a little while, it sometimes produces what the tight grip would have missed. Given room, people often move toward honesty on their own.
Open loops are not my natural habitat. They’re uncomfortable, and I’ve spent a long time closing them fast and calling that thoroughness.
The walk that afternoon was the last part of our conversation on those topics that day, and it ended because we arrived somewhere.
I’ve been carrying two of those questions since, and I still haven’t worked out whether that’s patience, or the older habit with a nice bow tie.
Three things to try.
1. Sort what closed from what didn’t
After an important conversation, take stock of what got resolved and what didn’t. Then notice our relationship to the open ones. Are we holding them open, or working them closed?
2. Ask whether it needs answering today
When we’re carrying something unanswered, the useful question is whether it needs resolution now, or whether it can wait for a moment with more room in it.
3. Leave one thing open on purpose
Try ending a conversation, even a small one, without reaching for full resolution. Leave a thread for next time, and see whether it feels like unfinished business or like space.
Enjoyed this post? Check out the Calm, mostly. workbook:
‘Becoming calmer. A practical guide to feeling steadier, and helping the people around you feel the same.’